I'm not generally a fan of 'comparing' wines. Wine is meant to stand on its own or with a meal - that's where the enjoyment comes from. Comparative tastings should only really be held for educational purposes. That said, this was a fun and illuminating way to spend the afternoon.
Bonny Doon Vineyards Ca' del Solo Nebbiolo 2005
Ruby with hints of that Nebbiolo rust - nice brilliance.
Intense cherry on the nose with a hint of tar, sage and wet stone. Perhaps a little green peppercorn.
Proper Nebbiolo on the palate - brilliantly rustic grip, bracing acidity, bunches of crunchy, soured cherries and that fantastic wet asphalt texture. Pebbles and purity with great balance. Bravo.
Fontanafredda Serralunga d'Alba Barolo 2004
Burnt ruby, nice depth.
Nose is smoky with flecks of black pepper, cherries and cranberries and a little whiff of bell pepper.
Bursting fruit on the palate - rich, toothsome and rambunctious. This is juicy stuff, again with incredible acidity and great texture. It's a bigger wine, but perhaps a wee bit lacking in the precision of the Bonny Doon. It makes up for it with exuberance.
Tasted 15/1/10 at Luvians Bottleshop
I think they're both brilliant wines but at the moment the Bonny Doon is showing better. Oddly, I prefer it because it strikes me as a great deal more 'old world' than the Barolo. Who'd have thought?